We've seen this scene play out before.
The victorious villain disappears backstage. His music stops. The arena is
quiet for a moment. Finally, the hero, gallant in defeat, stands in the middle
of the ring. The fans applaud. He soaks in this ultimate show of respect
before walking down the aisle, casting a final glance to the crowd before
heading back behind the curtain.
This is what was supposed to happen just before SummerSlam went off the air, but while the familiar actions were there, the emotion was not.
WWE wanted fans in attendance to feel sorry for Triple H after he tapped out to Brock
Lesnar. They didn't. They rejected this play for their sympathy with boos and
chants of "You tapped out!"
Triple H was supposed to appear valiant in defeat. Instead, he was
humiliated.
What went wrong?
It was a little over four months ago when a sold-out Sun Life Stadium roared with
approval and respect for Triple H, The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels after
their epic Hell In A Cell match at WrestleMania 28. Fans seized the opportunity
to show their appreciation for all three men. If you didn't get
chills while watching, you probably aren't a fan. It's been a long time since Triple H was beloved among hardcore fans, but he was embraced by them on that night.
Make no mistake about it, WWE got the reaction it wanted at WrestleMania.
So, what changed at SummerSlam?
My best guess is Paul Heyman. While the main event match at SummerSlam was Triple H
vs. Brock Lesnar, the feud was Triple H vs. Heyman.
Heyman holds a high level of respect among fans, and for weeks he was
badgered and bullied by Triple H. All that seemed to be fine until Raw 1,000,
when Stephanie McMahon got involved. Her words were so mean-spirited and
seemingly personal, you couldn't help but feel sorry for Heyman. Does anyone
really think his children are ashamed of him?
Brock Lesnar was now in the position of avenging his friend in their fight against the
authority figures he felt slighted by. It sounds noble, as long as you can
look past Lesnar breaking an arm or two.
WWE overplayed its hand with Triple H, and made a mistake
that's become all too common lately - forgetting what makes the good guys good
and the bad guys bad.